My Fair Lady 2012

source

 While trying to figure out titles for best costumes for the Academy Awards in February (entry to come) I happened upon Enchanted Serenity, which I occasionally trowel for costume drama news. Seems there's to be a new My Fair Lady! Adapted by Emma Thompson (a lady and a scholar). I'm assuming since it's called My Fair Lady and not Pygmalion they're keeping it a musical and am also assuming they'll keep the Lerner and Loewe score and lyrics. The latest news on the cast has Academy Award nominee Carey Mulligan (P&P '05, Bleak House, An Education) as Eliza and Hugh Grant as Thompson's pick for Higgins. That's right ladies and gentlemen, we've reached the time that Hugh Grant is old enough to play Henry Higgins!

I think Mulligan is a fine choice for Eliza. She's one of my absolute favorite new (if you've just discovered her as America has) talents and I'd love to see her play both sides of Eliza seeing as until now she's been rather prim and proper. I have no idea if she can sing, but here's hoping.

source

source

Grant as Higgins? Granted (haha) he is only Thompson's pick and there is no evidence that he's actually interested in the project, but doesn't he seem a tad inarticulate to play famed linguist Henry Higgins? I mean that's the schtick right? Bumbling but adorable (?) Hugh Grant. I don't know about this one. Enchanted Serenity has a list with its article of other possible Higgins including Daniel Craig, Colin Firth (role reversal from The King's Speech?), Hugh Jackman, Hugh Laurie (personal fave), Jeremy Northam etc. Who'da thunk we'd see the day when our favorite heroes mature into the role of Henry Higgins? Yes they are the right age, but Rex Harrison just seemed so much older than any of them ('sides maybe Hugh Laurie).  I only know that Hughes Jackman and Laurie can sing so...not that Higgins actually sings per se. Rex Harrison invented talk singing for My Fair Lady, so maybe I shouldn't rate them on musical ability...

source

source

source

 And my opinion on the project in general? I'm leaning toward "cool!". I've always longed to see the original cast with Julie Andrews i.e. an Eliza that did her own singing. I love Audrey Hepburn to bits, but in My Fair Lady she just doesn't do it for me as much as her other contemporary works. She's too waify for Eliza and for that period. I'd be excited to see a new face and form take the role. As for Rex Harrison, loved him and he IS Higgins to me, but again, I'd be excited to see a new take. Don't think I've forgotten the mess that was made of The Music Man w/ Matthew Broderick, but here's hoping under Emma Thompson's keen eye this project will be a nice reinvention, not replacement for or blotch on the original. I'd also be excited to see a new take on the costumes. With so many iconic pieces (the flower girl dress, the ascot and ball dresses) I'd love to see them turned on their head.


As a child My Fair Lady was my stay home sick movie and the ending always confused me and my mother couldn't explain it to me. Were they in love? weren't they? What on earth happens after she comes back? ****SPOILERS****I was actually pondering Pygmalion this morning oddly enough and how if you read Shaw's epilogue he's very adamant that Eliza and Higgins are not in love and do not get together and that supposing they are and do is dumb and is insulting to Eliza. She marries Freddy and has a relatively unremarkable life as she supports Freddy and becomes a fixture in Higgins and Pickering's lives. What will Thompson do with this? My high school had Higgins and Eliza kiss at the end which gave my childhood a lot of closure, but looking back I agree with Shaw (who wrote it, so you should too). While My Fair Lady is excellent at leaving the end very ambiguous I wouldn't mind Thompson making up our minds for us, siding w/ Shaw and myself of course.